Macy's Ratings and Reviews
Men
Red
Shop Now At Macy's
Shop Shoes or
Choose a Category

Customer Reviews for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals

This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Macy's.

Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals

The Unlisted Top Shelf Sandal is an intriguing blend of styles with a high-cut, gathered vamp, cutout sides and shapely, stacked wood heel.
Average Customer Rating:
4.304 out of 5
4.3
 out of 
5
(23 Reviews) 23
Open Ratings Snapshot
Rating Snapshot (23 reviews)
5 stars
12
4 stars
7
3 stars
3
2 stars
1
1 star
0
21 of 23(91%)reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Review 1 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarBJQG
from Minneapolis MN
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

Great way to complete a fun look

April 5, 2010
"Very excited to wear them to an upcoming concert. Really finish off outfit to make a great look."
Review 2 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarShoesIam
from New Jersey
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

Beautiful shoes

March 31, 2010
"I have a high arch and insole and was very happy with the perfect fit! I wish I had purchased them in taupe as well."
Review 3 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarDonnagirl325
from Queens, NY
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 30-39
What is your gender? Female

Sexy shoe

March 29, 2010
Reviewer Images
(click to see full-size image)
User submitted photo
"This shoe looks great on. They are very sexy & look great with skinny jeans. Unfortunately they are very uncomfortable. I wore them for about 4 hours the other night which included dancing. They rub a lot on the big toes which I put bandaids on & they helped a little. I had a hard time making the walk back to the hotel room to switch to flats. I love them though & will definitely wear them again. They have a very high heel & I am not used to wearing high heels so maybe someone who is would have better luck. For the price & style, I would definitely recommend buying them."
Review 4 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatarjohansa
from cedar park
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60

nice shoe but...

March 21, 2010
"my right big toe felt squished,,,went back and forth on keeping them, but alas will exchange for similiar pair..my boyfriend really liked them too..."
Review 5 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarjessMb
from louisville, ky
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? No
What is your age? 18-24
What is your gender? Female

very hot shoes!

March 18, 2010
"i just received these yesterday and they look great! it will take some time to break them in but i can't wait to wear them for my trip to nyc!"
Review 6 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarELRM
from AL
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 30-39
What is your gender? Female

March 14, 2010
"I really like this sandal, however I'm not use too wearing heels this high. I can walk in it fine, however not for long periods. If you're a pro walking in high heels this is a nice inexpensive sandal for you. The opening around the ankle isn't as snug as I feel it should be, but overall I would recommend this shoe to a friend. Good Buy!!!"
Review 7 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
2 out of 5
2 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
slightly small
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
slightly narrow
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
no arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? No
Customer AvatarFashionForward09
from PA
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 25-29
What is your gender? Female

Painful experience

March 13, 2010
"These shoes are definately not easy on the feet. The back slipped and rubbed my heel raw, and only from walking around the house a few times. They also have absolutely no arch support. Cute, but not worth the pain. They will be returned."
Review 8 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
3 out of 5
3 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
neutral
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
neutral
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarSxeShoe
from CA
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? No
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

Not for petite gramma

March 11, 2010
"Had a hard time climbing on these shoes...once there, the back flap was so uncomfortable, had to climb down! They are going back! Soo sad! They are for the younger and daring crowd and they are so cute, definite not for me. At least I dared!"
Review 9 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
4 out of 5
4 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
neutral
Runs Wide
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatarginphar
from Oceanside, CA
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? No
What is your age? 40-49
What is your gender? Female

March 5, 2010
"It a great shoes, the color is not what I expected to be, but over all, is a cute shoes"
Review 10 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatarnttm10
from CA
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 25-29
What is your gender? Female

March 4, 2010
"I like this a lot. This is true size and looks nice in them."
Review 11 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
slightly large
Runs Large
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatartoomuchwork
from wisconsin
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 40-49
What is your gender? Female

March 2, 2010
"These shoes are so cute! I really like them but my heel pops out. I'm gonna think about it, they may have to go back."
Review 12 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
slightly large
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
mostly narrow
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
slight arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarSibyl
from Atlanta
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? No
What is your age? 30-39
What is your gender? Male

Awesome

February 27, 2010
"Cute, cute, cute! I love these shoes and you can't beat the price. I can't wait to where them!"
Review 13 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
3 out of 5
3 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
neutral
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
slightly no arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? No
Customer Avatarchristid
from Kansas City, MO
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 40-49
What is your gender? Female

Cute shoes/not very comfortable

February 26, 2010
"First, they are NOT leather as stated - all MANMADE materials, they should correct the description. Kind of a weird angle to stand in, a little uncomfortable. Very stylish.
Cute heel. Not sure if I'm going to keep.
"
Review 14 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
neutral
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
mostly no arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatarmslovestotalk
from Kansas City,Missouri
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

February 12, 2010
"Love this shoe!!!! Looks a lot better in person.Goes with everything from jeans to a night on the town."
Review 15 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarJtsmom
from Sacramento CA
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

Very Nice

December 30, 2009
"These shoes are very nice looking and when I put them on they were so comfortable. I love them and can't wait to wear them out. They are so soft. They heel is high but not bad to walk in. I am so happy that I purchased them."
Review 16 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
3 out of 5
3 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
neutral
Runs Large
Runs Narrow
neutral
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
neutral
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarLilyDOrtigia
from Italy
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? No
What is your age? 30-39
What is your gender? Female

Little Disappointed

December 29, 2009
"In the discription of this shoe it reads that they are made of a leather upper, which they are not...they are all man made materials (one star loss). The back of the shoe is extremely stiff and is a pain in my achilles (second star loss). That having been said, they are an extremely stylish shoe, true to size/width and an exceptional value (I have not found them cheaper on other sites)."
Review 17 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Product Experience:
Runs Small
slightly large
Runs Large
No Arch Support
great arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarPixieMoose
from White Lake, MI
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 40-49
What is your gender? Female

LOVE These Shoes!

December 17, 2009
"I put these shoes on when they were delivered and fell in love! They feel GREAT and are extremely soft and comfortable for a heel this height. Sexy too! Boyfriend digs them. My ankles are slightly skinny so the ankle part is slightly loose but not loose enough to cause an issue. They're keepers for sure and I can't wait to wear them this weekend!"
Review 18 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarQuirkee
from Chicago Suburbs
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 50-60
What is your gender? Female

SEXY SEXY SEXY

November 23, 2009
"Ok-I have not worn heels this high in a very long time. I thought what the heck-I can fall just as easily in flat shoes. I am known as a major klutz. Anyways I tried these on and was pleasantly surprise how comfortable they are. I walked around the pergo floor in my house and realized I could do it-I can walk in high sexy shoes. "Practiced" a few more days and took them on vacation with me. Wow-so many compliments!!!! I wore them all day and didn't even fall or trip. Looked great with skirt or jeans."
Review 19 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
No Arch Support
good arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer AvatarSil28
from Colorado
How often do you shop at macys.com? Frequently
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 30-39
What is your gender? Female

October 22, 2009
"I love this sandals. They look so sexy and sophisticated at the same time. You get more for what you paid!! I'm really happy with my purchase."
Review 20 for Unlisted Shoes, Top Shelf Sandals
Overall Rating
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Runs Narrow
slightly narrow
Runs Wide
No Arch Support
good arch support
Arch Support
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Customer Avatarblakesl8
How often do you shop at macys.com? Occasionally
Are you a Macy's Credit Card holder? Yes
What is your age? 18-24
What is your gender? Female

October 16, 2009
"WHAT A STEAL! These shoes are even better than they look in the picture and fit amazingly and look awesome. I love them and they are even on sale. I would definitely recommend these. I'm so happy I bought them! They are comfortable and are good quality."
1 2 next>>